Historical Buildings in Tuscany – Should We Try to Save the Past?

By Abi King | Italy

Mar 31

Skull in the Charterhouse of Calci in Tuscany


Beneath the arches, a cloaked man walks through the shadows, his head bent, his hands supporting an open book. I can hear my footsteps, distorted through the darkness by the basement’s wet gravel, a hesitant chord to the beat of dripping water.

Upstairs, in the clouded daylight, it’s easier to see the wooden planks covering the windows and the words that scream “take my blood.” It’s also easier to see the table decked with homemade olive oil, bread and wine.

Historical Buildings in Tuscany

Decaying Nicosia Monastery with ghosts in TuscanyThis is the Nicosia Monastery, a place that chalked up nearly 800 years of active service before the last few monks hung up their cassocks in the 1970s and the vandals moved in. Among the ripped plaster and violent graffiti, a neatened orange grove provides fragrance and a sense of peace.

It’s being painstakingly restored by the Nicosia Nostra, a volunteer organisation founded in 2004 from people in the neighbourhood who wanted to save the place. They host outdoor concerts in summer, construct nativities in winter, and spend the rest of the year lurking in basements to scare the bejesus out of visiting writers.

And they’re not the only ones.

Agustino Agustini greets me in the hallway of Villa di Corliano, a house, no make that a mansion, complete with a driveway that sweeps through the grounds like a flourish from a period drama. Florentine eagles flit across the vault, while whispers of ghosts hide behind chandeliers.

A chill follows us through the towering doors, while Roman statues stand guard.

“Teresa,” Agustini tells me, remembering the real-life ghostbusters who stayed here. “People come to see Teresa della Seta Bocca Gaetani.”


He smiles and slips his hands into his pockets. “The ghost who makes you laugh.”

Like the Nicosia Monastery, Villa di Corliano’s has 21st century problems. Upkeep is expensive and the high society who summered here have long since gone. Yet Agustini seems quietly optimistic. He’s opened his home to visitors, although he’s keen to emphasise the nature of the experience.

Roman statue in Villa di Corliano - A house with ghosts in Tuscany“There’s no swimming pool here,” he says, “and we won’t install air conditioning. The people who come here, who love our family home, want something more than the latest hotel. They want to see the real Tuscany.”

And Teresa, I suppose.

Later on, we find more ghosts from the past – but this time no-one’s laughing. In unmarked graves, the Charterhouse monks of Calci used death to extend their earthly vows of silence into eternity.

While the brothers ran the pharmacy, the fathers lived reclusive lives, speaking only once a year and passing food between walled tunnels to avoid the temptation for a chat.

Yet despite this severity, austerity never really caught on.

The Charterhouse notches up an impressive 1500 rooms, plus a view of the leaning tower of Pisa on that infamous clear day. Living quarters come with private orchards, while cloisters overlook fountains and a gated panorama of Tuscany at its best.

In fact, it’s this very richness that’s the real curse in this part of Tuscany. With the splendours of Florence and Pisa nearby, little attention remains for buildings that would otherwise be protected, promoted and thriving.

Like the others, the Charterhouse is struggling. The last monks left in the 1970s, leaving the cloisters crumbling behind them.
Part of me wonders whether this is how things need to be. That it’s impossible to restore and remember everything and that in trying to do so we risk losing today’s resources.

Yet I cannot deny the beauty of these places: not only in their frescoes and fragrance, but in the joy and enthusiasm of those so eager to save these ghosts – for the future.

 (Abigail King)
Nicosia MonasteryVolunteers run the tours and organise concerts here. Contact their organisation, Nicosia Nostra
Villa di Corliano Book a stay in this grand house or simply enjoy the restaurant. Ghost sightings not guaranteed.
The Charterhouse of Calci Guided tours available.
I visited these “off the beaten track” parts of Tuscany as a guest of Marco from Casa Gentili. Marco himself left his corporate position to run a bed and breakfast in the house that has been in his family for 100 years. Like the Villa di Corliano, it’s a place to visit for the atmosphere rather than the air conditioning.


About the Author

Abigail King is a writer and photographer who swapped a career as a doctor for a life on the road. Now published by Lonely Planet, the BBC, CNN, National Geographic Traveler & more, she feels most at home experimenting here: covering unusual journeys, thoughtful travel and luxury on www.insidethetravellab.com

Keith Jenkins March 31, 2011

Absolutely brilliant post Abi! Wow!

Jenna April 6, 2011

Interesting! You raise a really good question about preserving this kind of place when so many great treasures in Florence and other towns are nearby. Plus, Italy has not been spending enough to preserve Pompeii, ancient Rome, etc., so it seems that preserving most smaller places will be up to private individuals or organizations…and many will fall into ruin, I suppose.
Thank you for introducing us to this wonderful slice of Tuscany.

    Abi King May 11, 2011

    It’s tricky, isn’t it. It was hugely uplifting to see the passion of the volunteers, though. They’re all beautiful places and definitely worth visiting.

Serena April 7, 2011

Hi Abi,
very nice post! I also recommend a visit to the Castle of Fosdinovo near Massa where ghosts and legends mix up with medieval history and noir love stories…checkfor further infos on http://www.castellodifosdinovo.it/en/storia-leggende.php
Guided tours are available.

    Abi King May 11, 2011

    Oh no! That would mean I’d have to return to Tuscany. How tiresome…;)

Helena Ewing May 5, 2011

great to see this being mentioned

Sofie March 13, 2013

Very nicely written!
It’s a though question, what to restore and what to let go.
Especially when you look at the financial burdens that sometimes come with restoring.

MaremmaBlog October 6, 2013

Italy does need this kind of place to be preserved, they cater for niche tourism and provide authentic experiences alternative to mass tourism. Great post!

Comments are closed