Why You Should Travel to the Bahamas Green Turtle Cay

You are here Home > Destinations > The Caribbean > Why You Should Travel to the Bahamas Green Turtle Cay

Why should you travel to the Bahamas Green Turtle Cay? Amid pure Caribbean shores and rum cocktails, you’ll also find a slice of New England here in the Abacos.  

This adventure pairs well with the secret things to do in Nassau itinerary here.

Abigail King looking out to see in Bahamas Green Turtle Cay
Paradise unlocked

The Unforgettable Bahamas Green Turtle Cay

The ancient Babylonians invented a way of measuring time by capturing shadows on stone: sun dials. Green Turtle Cay measures time by bouncing shadows through palm trees onto soft pink walls in a piece of New Plymouth brought to the Bahamas.

This post contains affiliate links, which means that if you book through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I travelled as part of a work project with The Bahamas Tourist Office, UK. However, what I chose to write about is mine, all mine! Bwahaha etc

Green Turtle Cay Map and walkway
Taking a stroll along the boardwalk

How to Get From Nassau to Green Turtle Cay

After three cracking days on the “mainland” of Nassau (more about that later,) our group had split into pairs to cover a handful of the 700 or so islands that make up the Bahamas chain.

A 35 minute flight from Nassau to Marsh Harbour and we were in the Abacos.

A 40 minute drive and 30 minute open-ferry later and we were on the white sands of Green Turtle Cay.

Travelling on a ferry in the Abaco islands
The ferry ride is an experience in itself

About Green Turtle Cay

Green Turtle Cay measures 3 1/2 miles by half a mile and almost everyone uses golf carts or ferries. The geography curls in and out like a diplodocus, a coy one, slowly stretching out each limb as though waking from a nap.

At Bluff House, Molly greets us at reception, a manager who moved here years ago to fall in love, raise a family and oversee this small, sweet boutique hotel.

OK, that’s not the official version, but it’s more or less what happened.

Abigail King in hammock
Exploring my new home at Bluff House

Bluff House Resort Marina

Bluff House, like the rest of the Abacos, is a mix. Spacious suites that overlook the ocean, decked in cool white, with fans, dark furniture and turquoise cushions among shell-encrusted boxes. And fully equipped homes, with kitchen, dining and living areas.

Not surprisingly for the Caribbean, the pace of life is slow, for all its American fast-food chains. The Bahamas achieved independence from Britain in 1973, their territory tickling the tips from east of the Florida Keys, past Cuba down to Haiti.

But the proximity to Florida results in a distinctly American feel with obligatory gratuities, take-away cups the size of a telescope and the use of the words vacation and rentals.

Speaking over cracked conch at the Tranquil Turtle Beach Bar, I mention this observation to Molly.

“Just wait until tonight,” she replies. “I’ll be interested to hear what you think.”

Golf buggy on Green Turtle Cay Bahamas
THE way to get around on the island!

Towards New Plymouth

Sunset sees us hit the golf cart, spinning through the villas and cottages of the resort before finally breaking free and hitting the open road.

And it is a surprisingly open road at this point, with ample room for cars and, shall we say, a conspicuous absence of street lights and standard signposts.

Trusty deputy-north-star Google Maps is struggling and it takes a good five minutes for us to work out how to turn the lights on.

But this is the stuff travel adventures are made of, right? It’s just that Bond makes it look so much better…

Travelling Around Green Turtle Cay

And then we’re off, the salty spray mingling sweetness and sweat, the hint of coconut and rum that sing-songs through the air.

The ferry earlier had helped us get our bearings. Small and open-backed, the ferries transport tourists, for sure, but more often they’re for Green Turtle Cay commuters and off-island cargo.

Barrels of drinking water, boxes of salsa, tins of cooking oil. In the middle of the day, we ferried alone but by evening and morning, it’s sardine-like seating with supplies to the island.

On dry land, we fly past hand-made signposts that signal the itinerary for the next few days: the Green Turtle Club for dining and Brendal’s Dive Shop for the Adventure Reef Snorkel.

New Plymouth Green Turtle Cay Skyline
Approaching New Plymouth on Green Turtle Cay

New Plymouth and the Surprise

But the focus for tonight is the dignified destination of New Plymouth, and the more dubious signature cocktail of the Goombay smash at Miss Emily’s Blue Bee Bar.

By some miracle, and a heart-warming intervention by locals on a hilltop, we arrive.

And then I understand.

For New Plymouth is not really like England at all.

It is like New England. Only newer.

House in New Plymouth Green Turtle Cay
New New Plymouth

New New Plymouth

Newer white picket fences with Caribbean colours: conch pink, lavender and lilac and a sky-high, hoping cornflower blue.

For it turns out that, this became the home of the New Englanders on the losing side of the American War of Independence.

Those loyal to the crown largely dispersed, some returning to England, others (quite sensibly) seeking somewhere warmer.

And so this is the new New Plymouth.

A second start at a brave new world.

Finding History

The Loyalist Memorial Sculpture Garden and the Albert Lowe Museum cover the establishment side of things.

But the real sense of place and history comes from the streets and sinews of New Plymouth itself.

Because above all else, it’s not stuck in a loyalist past.

Welcome to Green Turtle Cay Bahamas
Don’t mind if I do!

The Goombay Smash

Outside the powder -blue portico of Miss Emily’s Blue Bee Bar, it’s time for a new invention: the Goombay Smash.

Miss Emily, sadly, passed away but her creation lives on, although apparently only this place knows the original. The secret mix involves rum, dirty rum, coconut rum and apricot rum. Oh, and a splash or two of pineapple juice.

Not surprisingly, it packs a punch.

And being the good, conscientious people that we are, mindful of the return journey, we decline to finish them all. While the preacher sweats and sings in the basketball court opposite, the sun slinks away, its work done for another day.

Which raises another question. Where are those lights on the golf buggy? And how do we get back to Bluff House?

Swap the goombay smash for a vodka martini and we’d be just like James Bond.

Or not.

Things to Do in Green Turtle Cay

Snorkelling and Boat Trip with Brendal’s

Take a day’s vacation from your troubles and cares with a trip from Brendal’s dive shop. Zip along between the blue of the sky and the water and then swim in clear, clear shores.

There’s an optional chance to swim with turtles – and even sharks.

And then have the freshest of beach lunches, rustled up for you right there on the shore.

Swimming with turtles and sharks in the Bahamas
A look at the underwater world in Green Turtle Cay

Green Turtle Club Resort and Marina

For a calmer sunset adventure, locals recommend the Green Turtle Club for all the things it can do with a lobster. Tacos, cracked lobster bites, lobster potato skins… I opted for the lobster and artichoke ravioli with basil pesto cream and cherry tomatoes.

Have a Goombay Smash at Miss Emily’s Blue Bee Bar

Brace yourself for the island’s signature cocktail. Mixing all kinds of rum, apricot brandy and pineapple juice, you’ll feel relaxed but be in no position to drive. They also serve food ;-)

Abigail King in Miss Emily Blue Bee Bar
Home of the Goombay Smash

Visit the Loyalist Memorial Sculpture Garden

Laid out to reflect the Union Jack, it’s a curious look at a particular point in time.

Visit Coco Bay Beach

Soft sand and clear water, this is a place for nature lovers rather than partygoers.

Day Trips From Green Turtle Cay

Head back to the mainland via Treasure Cay and a drive to Marsh Harbour to take ferries to see the following:

Man-O-War Shipbuilding Island

As you might expect, boats are a big deal in a place with 700 islands. A day trip to the Man-o-War island reveals the shipbuilding yards, gift shops and pretty-as-a-picture pastel streets.

Man O War ferry dock and church with people
Man O War: shipbuilding and instagram backgrounds

The Elbow Cay Lighthouse in Hope Town

Along with boats, lighthouses play a prominent role in this maritime destination. The lighthouse at Elbow Cay is one of the last operational kerosene-fuelled lighthouses in the world.

Built in 1862, it has survived war, independence and the adjustments to new navigational equipment, thanks to the work of tireless volunteers.

You can climb to the top for a view of the marina. Take the ferry from Marsh Harbour to Hope Town, but ask for the lighthouse stop specifically, otherwise you’ll head into Hope Town. With its work from Victorian England, the fixtures and fittings do seem very British.

Woman climbing Elbow Cay Lighthouse
This is the easy part of the climb…

How to Get to Green Turtle Cay

From Nassau on New Providence Island check (the main island in the Bahamas,) take a 35 minute domestic flight to Marsh Harbour in the Abacos. It’s a 40 minute drive from the airport to Treasure Cay and then a short ferry hop across to Green Turtle Cay.

The ferry makes several stops: at Bluff House, for example, and direct to New Plymouth marina so be sure to make sure you know where you are before you disembark ;-)

From Bluff House, it’s around 40 minutes or so to New Plymouth by golf buggy. But be prepared to get lost!

Bluff House collage of images in the Bahamas Green turtle Cay
Staying at Bluff House

Where to Stay on Green Turtle Cay

We stayed at Bluff House, an unpretentious hotel and villa marina resort with spectacular view of the sea and the odd, welcome hammock. There is a pool but the beach is the main draw.

The beachside bar, The Tranquil Turtle serves classic Bahamian fare like cracked conch and conch fritters, as well as a low-key breakfast after 8.

The Ballyhoo Bar and Grill offers views across the marina and arranges live music and dancing. It’s a family-friendly place with a small shop and its own signature drink: the Tranquil Turtle. Like the Goombay Smash, it’s strong and based on rum!

You need to arrange to hire a golf cart separately, but the staff at Bluff house can help with that.

Bahamas Green Turtle Cay: What to Know

  • Take cash – USD. It’s not impossible to pay by card but cash is easier.
  • Adjust to island time. Expect up to an hour for service at reception, restaurants, dive shops, bars etc.
  • EXCEPTION! The ferries are very strict about time! Be punctual at the dock!
  • From personal experience, I’d advise women not to travel on their own to New Plymouth after dark.
  • Lather up with sunscreen and hats and take insect repellent with you.
  • Try a Goombay Smash. And a Tranquil Turtle. But maybe not on the same night.
  • Relax and enjoy the beauty of the place!

More About Travel in the Caribbean

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.